How to Create a Lead Magnet That Actually Gets Leads?

How to Create and Market a Lead Magnet

Lead generation is one of the most effective marketing tactics to build up revenue and generate your own business asset you can turn to when you need (e.g. when your traffic is slowing down).

Creating and marketing a lead magnet helps you generate more leads and start those relationships with your current and potential customers going.

What is a Lead Magnet?

A lead magnet (also known as a “opt-in bribe” and a “content upgrade”) is a free digital product (download, access to something, etc.) that entices people to opt in to your email list.

It works like this:

  • You create a useful free product (usually it’s a digital product, like a free eBook, a free whitepaper, or a free access to a video course or a free webinar)
  • You create forms for your site users to complete to receive the product
  • They sign up and you send them the product right away (using email automation)
  • Based on the lead magnet your site users initially opted in for, you continue to market to them until they convert into actual buyers

Here’s our own example of a lead magnet:

Lead magnet example

Lead magnets make a perfect secondary conversion goal (for those people who are not ready to buy yet). As the name suggests, lead magnets are used for lead generation, and there are lots of ways they can help you engage more of your site users (More on these below)

According to various case studies, when done well, lead magnets can make a huge difference to your lead generation strategy:

  • Brian Harris saw a 20-30% opt-in rate from blog posts where he linked to several of his lead magnets
  • Brian Dean used saw a boost his conversions by 785% in one day by using lead magnets
Conversion rate increase
One-day conversion boost after adding a lead magnet

What Makes a Good Lead Magnet?

A lead magnet largely relies on “Zero-Price Effect“: people tend think that there’s no downside to “free:”

Humans make decisions without rationalizing the outcomes of their choices… when something is FREE! we forget the downside. FREE! gives us such an emotional charge that we perceive what is being offered as immensely more valuable than it really is

So the main thing about a lead magnet is that it’s free, and this makes it an incredibly useful marketing tool.

Additionally, a good lead magnet:

  • Solves your target audience problems (using case studies, personal experience, etc.)
  • Offers an actionable piece of advice that can be instantly put in practice
  • Makes complicated data easy to consume (through summaries, takeaways and/or visualizations and videos)
  • Ties your potential customer closer to your brand by providing real value and an incentive to keep it handy (e.g. a checklist)
  • Compliments your front-end product (e.g. offers tutorials, maybe even “soft-sells” your product features as the solution to a common problem)
  • Doesn’t distract / prevent users from buying your primary product (This is very important!)

How to Create Lead Magnets That Convert Like Crazy?

With all the above criteria in mind, to create an effective lead magnet, you need to (1) thoroughly analyze your existing opportunities as well as (2) build additional landing pages to attract more leads naturally:

(1) Determine where your site currently needs a secondary conversion funnel, i.e. a lead magnet:

  • Identify all queries, especially those with clearly informational** intent, that bring you traffic
    • **An informational search intent is when your potential customer does not intend to buy. They use Google to research (but may be either convinced to buy right away or at least opt in to buy later)
  • Evaluate your current conversions of all the corresponding landing pages
  • Tweak your conversion funnels on all of those to either:
    • Entice a customer to buy right away (using effective Upsellselling strategy)
    • OR Encourage a customer to opt-in to your email list for you to be able to reach out to them later, when they are ready to buy (e.g. in time for holidays when a buying intent is higher). This is when a lead magnet comes in handy.

Google Analytics “User Flow” report is an easy way to identify pages that attract traffic but struggle to engage users. The report gives a graphical representations of the paths users are taking through your site. Select “Source” as a starting dimension and you’ll see your traffic sources at a glance, the most popular landing pages and where the users headed next.

Hover over any landing page to see its total visits, the number of drop-offs (i.e. people that left without taking any kind of an action) and the amount of through traffic (i.e. how many users went to another page of your site).

Google Analytiics Flow

You can also click on the landing page to see traffic through that page highlighted. This gives you a solid understanding of how each landing page acquires and loses clicks and some ground for brainstorming how to utilize that traffic better:

Google Analytis highlight

(2) Come up with more ideas, i.e. discover content gaps you can close

One of the most effective ways to come up with more lead magnets is to run a niche question research. Knowing which questions people type into Google’s search box gives you an incredible amount of insight into what they are struggling with and how you might be able to help them.

Google’s People Also Ask results help you collect some questions based on your query. Note that People Also Ask boxes are infinite: As you start clicking the questions, it will open up more and more questions below, so you can get a solid list in the end:

People Also Ask

Many of those questions can be both a lead magnet idea and a good keyword to optimize your landing page promoting it.

Google bases these boxes on user behavior, so there should be enough people typing them in the search box. So these questions give you some insight into which information is in high demand.

More tools to research niche questions:

Ahrefs questions
Use Ahrefs “Questions” tab to research niche questions

Possible ideas for a good lead magnet:

  • A free eBook guiding through a process of setting up / creating something
  • A private case-study whitepaper / checklist / worksheets of how to achieve better results in
  • A free access to a video course
  • A cheatsheet that makes complicated / hard-to-remember steps easy to follow. This can be a printable asset too.
  • A free (Excel, PSD, etc.) template (or even a free theme). Think of free swipe files, branding kits, templates of social media policies, sample client proposals, meal planners, calendars, etc.
  • A free toolkit (collection of free tools) or free resources. These are great opportunities for partnerships with the developers behind those tools.

How to Create a Lead Magnet? A Step by Step Guide

So you’ve singled out some lead magnet topic ideas. What’s next? How to actually create a lead magnet. Let’s outline the simplest process:

Step 1: Research, and then research some more

You want to identify the structure of your lead generation (i.e. what to cover) and its future format. For structure, dig some more into specific questions within your identified topic, find related tools and come up with the most suitable content format(s). For example, that could be an eBook with a helpful checklist that outlines the process.

Step 2: Think how you can re-package your old content

It’s a good idea to keep your existing content in mind, for higher efficiency. Think which content you have ever created that answers your identified questions and how to use it.

For example, here’s a detailed tutorial on how to re-package your old content into a video course, which makes a great lead magnet, and how you can end up in even more content assets (podcats, GIFs, etc.) on your way there:

Video course re-package
If you plan to produce video content, think how you can re-package it into more assets, e.g. podcasts, an audiobook, an eBook and a video course. These could be powerful lead magnets you create with less effort

Step 3: Figure out possible collaboration opportunities

Do you know what makes an even better lead magnet?

The better-than-awesome lead magnet is one that promotes itself and drives not only leads, but also clicks.

There is no better way to create an asset that promotes itself than inviting niche influencers who will help you build it.

Collaboration is the powerful marketing tactic for creating long-term projects. Invite niche bloggers and social media influencers to contribute their thoughts, and offer to feature them on the landing page. This will be a powerful incentive for them to help you promote the final asset.

Influencer driven content
Various types of influencer-driven content that can be turned into lead magnets

Step 4: Use tools to build your lead magnet

Luckily, there are tools for just about anything these days, so you may even keep the whole lead magnet creation process in-house, if you want to. Here are a few tools that will help you put together various lead magnets:

  • Create Infographics: Visme is a great tool to put together professionally-looking infographics (as well as charts, checklists, etc.) and presentations on your own
  • Turn text content into PDF eBooks and whitepapers: There’s a variety of tools (including Google Docs PDF export) but FreePDFConvert makes the best job preserving all clickable links and making the export looks stunning
  • Create videos and video series: Animatron lets you create explainer videos (Studio) and professional promotional videos (Wave.video) easily.

How to Get More Leads with a Lead Magnet?

So you have your lead magnet created (It’s not a rocket science!), now what? How to use the lead magnet to actually get leads?

Here are a few ideas:

Use the lead magnet on you exit intent popups

An exit intent popup is a popup that shows up just when your visitor is about to leave. They have been proven to be an effective marketing tactic catching almost lost leads. Putting your lead magnet on them to build up your list is definitely a smart idea.

PayKickstart offers you an easy way to set those up using “Exit-Intent Pop-up on Checkout

Just enable this feature inside the Edit Product Settings. You can control the popup message and pick a design:

Exit intent popup
Set up your exit popup using PayKickStart

[Encourage your customer to complete the purchase and also offer your lead magnet as a free incentive!]

Use the lead magnet to improve efficiency of your Facebook ads

Facebook advertising doesn’t work well for all niches or for all types of products. In many cases, it’s smarter to use a secondary conversion funnel to collect leads first and then to market your product to them. For more information on this tactic, check out Susan Wenograd’s great guide on using Facebook advertising effectively.

Facebook advertising lead magnets

[Use your lead magnet to generate leads from Facebook ads, then sell to them later by nurturing your relationships]

Give away your lead magnet on a “Thank You for Your Purchase” Page

Your job is not done once a purchase is made. Your current customers are your biggest asset because they are much more likely to buy again than a new lead. Start developing your relationships with your customers by giving away your lead magnet after they purchased from you. This will be a nice surprise for your customer as well as a way for you to tie them closer to your brand.

PayKickstart new sleek “Thank you” page offers you a nice place to link to your lead magnet download:

Thank with lead magnet
Offer your lead magnet as a free bonus after your customer has made a purchase

[Give your customers something to take home and remember you by]

Make it your blog default call-to-action

Your blog is likely to attract users who are looking for information, rather than to buy. Just like with Facebook ads, it may be a better idea to match your offer to that intent and offer them free downloads instead of buying your front-end project.

You can certainly combine the two CTAs (e.g. explain how your products solve the described problem and “soft-sell” them from the context while inviting the readers to download your lead magnet from the blog-wide sidebar), but in most cases a free download makes a perfect primary conversion channel for the business blog:

Blog lead magnet

Create a separate library of lead magnets

Once you have a few lead magnets created, go ahead and create your own library (i.e. “Knowledge center”). Make sure to optimize the page for major informational queries in your niche to attract natural leads from search engines.

Check out this Paykickstart Marketing Library that contains our collection of useful freebies:

Lead magnet

Good luck creating an effective lead magnet!